Floyd said:
Wasn't it Pete Rose who absolutely smoked a catcher at home in an All-Star game? Yeah, I'd say there was a time it was taken seriously. Though I do like the lighter side. - Like when Kruk (I think it was turned) his helmet bachwards when facing Randy Johnson.
It was Ray Fosse he hit and actually hurt. I don't know that's the best example of anything other than Pete Rose being a jerk but, yeah, it meant more at the time.
It really is the simplest solution in the world. The problem is it would take some actual competent leadership from Bud Selig. Here's how it would go.
1. Make the point to teams, players and management that the All-Star game is important. Don't suggest it. Don't imply it. Lay it out simply. It's a game you're trying to win. Loafing or not taking it seriously will be seen the same as taking a regular game off.
That shouldn't be hard. The All-Star game
is important. It's important financially, it's important promotionally.
2. Reduce the rosters to 24 a squad, split into 10 pitchers and 14 position players.
Again, simple. Being an All-star should be an elite thing. The best of the best. Not one of 70.
3. Mandate how players are used. The starting pitchers go three innings(or, if they run into trouble, they at least have to start the third inning) and starting position players play a minimum of six innings.
Right now the dumbest thing about the All-Star game is that it's often decided in the late innings by the scrubs and Kansas City Royals who have no business being there. None of the athletes care about the NHL or NBA all-star game either but at least in those cases we get to watch Sid Crosby and Lebron James not giving a damn late in the game instead of Joel Hanrahan pitching to Paul Konerko. three position players, at a minimum, would play the whole game.
4. Build the teams like real teams.
5-6 starting pitchers. 4 or 5 relievers. A guy at each position. A spare catcher. A spare outfielder. A spare infielder. A couple of bats off the bench. The starter, as mentioned, goes, three innings. Then each starting pitcher goes an inning or two. Use relievers in the 8th or 9th. Plan on not using some guys in case it goes to extras.
That's it. Tell them to care about it. Tell them to treat it like a real game. Make sure they know that playing in the All-Star game means, horrors of horrors, they have to play another baseball game.