• For users coming over from tmlfans.ca your username will remain the same but you will need to use the password reset feature (check your spam folder) on the login page in order to set your password. If you encounter issues, email Rick couchmanrick@gmail.com

2024-25 Toronto Maple Leafs General Discussion

The only position I feel confident in with this team is in net. The lack of depth up front and on the D is really concerning and personally going to be hard for Tre to improve. He may be able to tinker with the lineup but going to be tough to improve it unless he deals another 1st which I hope he doesn't. The real changes will hopefully come at the end of the season which is the route they need to take. Quit selling off picks it hasn't worked and the main reason why are farm system sucks. Hopefully everyone is healthy come playoff time and they play like they did for a stretch back in November when they actually looked like a team. If they cave in the playoffs then you tear this team down. It already should have happened but I don't see that happening again if they shit the bed AGAIN.
 
I'm pretty positive about this team.

I know fundamentally they don't have it to make a deep run. We already have enough evidence of that. Without changes in the Core, there is no Cup (IMHO).

However what is good is that there were material positive changes over the past 18 months...... beyond minor or temporary attempts to modify around the edges or with rentals (i.e. the Dubas method).

Material Improvements over Past 18 Months:

1. Treliving
2. Berube
3. Stolarz
4. Tanev
5. Major improvement in low event defensive hockey

No#s 3, 4, 5 are combos that steal series.


Notwithstanding my lack of confidence in the 4 Lovely Lads......I think the crease and blue line makes a big difference. Like I said, I'm pretty positive.
 
At the risk of being shat upon, and agreeing that Dubas made some pretty big errors in giving away so much, you
have to acknowledge that an unprecedented world pandemic absolutely slammed the Leafs most who like I'm sure everyone
else did, banked on the Cap increasing and thus bringing those over-pay contracts back into a reasonable level and would
have allowed for the opportunity to sign much better support players and thus not the need to toss draft picks away.

It just matches being a Leaf fan but THAT was juuuusssttt a bit over the top Hockey Gods....
 
At the risk of being shat upon, and agreeing that Dubas made some pretty big errors in giving away so much, you
have to acknowledge that an unprecedented world pandemic absolutely slammed the Leafs most who like I'm sure everyone
else did, banked on the Cap increasing and thus bringing those over-pay contracts back into a reasonable level and would
have allowed for the opportunity to sign much better support players and thus not the need to toss draft picks away.

It just matches being a Leaf fan but THAT was juuuusssttt a bit over the top Hockey Gods....
As I outlined in a prior post.... successful teams with amazing drafted talent will sign ELCs, then Bridge Contracts, then AFTER there is evidence the talent can win, sign the "player-friendly - NMC - Mega Contracts"

This is what Chicago did for example with Toews and Kane and won multiple cups.

Dubas went straight from ELC to Mega Contracts. Which meant no carrot.....all the comfort....and all the cap money in the forwards.

Every team had to deal with covid. In fact, Covid handed the Leafs best chance at a Cup in decades.....which Leafs handed over to an inferior MTL.

The Leaf architecture before covid was amatuer hour.

But again.... thats in the past.

I like it that there have been changes. The Core4 will never ever change. They will always be the same guys.....so don't expect them to surprise you in April.

But maybe Stolarz might!
 
I'm pretty positive about this team.

I know fundamentally they don't have it to make a deep run. We already have enough evidence of that. Without changes in the Core, there is no Cup (IMHO).

However what is good is that there were material positive changes over the past 18 months...... beyond minor or temporary attempts to modify around the edges or with rentals (i.e. the Dubas method).

Material Improvements over Past 18 Months:

1. Treliving
2. Berube
3. Stolarz
4. Tanev
5. Major improvement in low event defensive hockey

No#s 3, 4, 5 are combos that steal series.


Notwithstanding my lack of confidence in the 4 Lovely Lads......I think the crease and blue line makes a big difference. Like I said, I'm pretty positive.
Generally agree but they still have to score some goals. Otherwise, they'll lose a lot of 2-1 games - again.
 
I have no issue having discussions. Nor do I have an issue with opposing view points. It's the flip flopping that grows tiresome. Many posters have little to say when the team is on a 5 game win streak. They then flood a thread as soon as a few losses in a row occur.
It's amazing how little some say when they're winning a game but if they're losing they've got lots to say and it's the same crap over and over again. Some prefer to be negative it seems.
 
As I outlined in a prior post.... successful teams with amazing drafted talent will sign ELCs, then Bridge Contracts, then AFTER there is evidence the talent can win, sign the "player-friendly - NMC - Mega Contracts"

This is what Chicago did for example with Toews and Kane and won multiple cups.

Dubas went straight from ELC to Mega Contracts. Which meant no carrot.....all the comfort....and all the cap money in the forwards.
Im just pointing out facts, but just quickly, MacKinnon, Mcdavid, Makar, Quinn and Jack Hughes, Stamkos, Brady Tkachuk, and Draisaitl did not have bridge deals. And I’m sure there are more.
 
I look at the positives. Leafs have been in a slump for about a week, I fully expect them to pull out of it and win when it counts most - against the Habs on Saturday night.
 
Im just pointing out facts, but just quickly, MacKinnon, Mcdavid, Makar, Quinn and Jack Hughes, Stamkos, Brady Tkachuk, and Draisaitl did not have bridge deals. And I’m sure there are more.
That's not a fact.

MacKinnon signed ELC and then a Bridge Contract for $6.3m and then AFTER the Avs won a Cup he signed for the Mega Contract at $12.6m.

Again.... contracts need reciprocity. You need a "carrot" where if there is performance, they will eventually get more. If you give them everything without getting that performance, you spoil the player because they are comfortable.
 
That's not a fact.

MacKinnon signed ELC and then a Bridge Contract for $6.3m and then AFTER the Avs won a Cup he signed for the Mega Contract at $12.6m.

Again.... contracts need reciprocity. You need a "carrot" where if there is performance, they will eventually get more. If you give them everything without getting that performance, you spoil the player because they are comfortable.
7 years at 6.3 isn’t a bridge. Look at what his stats were compared to Marner’s at the time he signed that deal.

I’m not saying Marner didn’t get paid too soon, but his stats lined up with ‘future’ pay. You have to look at it in context. I’m sure they were thinking the cap would rise significantly. It was a gamble that doesn’t look fantastic in retrospect but it’s what happened.

So yes, these are facts.
 
Back
Top